Chapter Depersonalized Case Histories in the Babylonian Therapeutic Compendia

Chapter Depersonalized Case Histories in the Babylonian Therapeutic Compendia

作者:Cale Johnson, J.
ISBN:9781501510762; 9781501502521, 9781501502507
语言:English
出版社:De Gruyter
格式:Pdf
资源下载
此资源为免费资源,请先后下载

Keywords

early scientific thought; compilation and redaction in the ancient world; infrastructural compendia; empiricism

Abstract

Standard histories of medicine identify Hippocratic texts such as Epidemics as the earliest medical case histories in human history. In contrast to the Hippocratic case histories, it is often stated that Babylonian medicine made no use of individual case histories. In this paper, I investigate ‘depersonalized case histories’ in the Babylonian therapeutic corpora (ca. 800–600 BCE, although in many cases probably based on earlier lost sources). On the face of it, the suggestion that certain complex collocations of symptoms derive in a straightforward way from individual cases might seem far-fetched, or at minimum not a demonstrable interpretation. Comparison of Babylonian therapeutic texts with the treatment of ‘cases’ in Mesopotamian law, in particular in so-called imperial rescripts in which an individual case is converted into a general statute, suggests that certain clusters of symptom descriptions actually represent ‘depersonalized’ case histories in which personal details have been intentionally omitted from the tradition in order to make these cases suitable for inclusion within authoritative(or as I suggest we call them infrastructural) technical corpora. The identification of this process of ‘depersonalization’ may also play an important role in bringing epistemological critiques of one kind or another (Foucault on ‘the clinical sciences’ or Forrester on ‘thinking incases’) into a fruitful dialogue with Mesopotamian materials.

资源下载此资源仅限注册用户下载,请先
资源下载
作者:Cale Johnson, J.
ISBN:9781501510762; 9781501502521, 9781501502507
语言:English
出版社:De Gruyter
格式:Pdf

如果您有任何问题,请随时与我们联系,谢谢。Chapter Depersonalized Case Histories in the Babylonian Therapeutic Compendia 内容均搜集于网络,本身不存储任何资源,如侵犯到您的权益,请提交反馈,我们将配合您第一时间删除。

0
封面图

评论0